Monday, 18 January 2016

The "It's Kosher" business


On the Ben Pekuah Facebook page a video can be seen of R' Meir Rabi and Rabbi Pinchas Padwa tasting meat from a Ben Pekuah animal.  Although R' Meir Rabi has eaten this meat many times he chose to make two brachot at this time. One bracha was Shechechiyanu and the other one was She'oso Nissim.  While it is puzzling that he made a Shechechiyanu I would like to explain why he made the bracha She'oso Nissim.
R' Meir is in fact a true miracle for numerous reasons.
Together with his business partner Kalman Gradman, R' Meir runs the It's Kosher Authority and associated businesses.

There are many differences between the Kosher certification business run by R' Rabi and Mr Gradman and the three main communal Kashrut organisations in Sydney and Melbourne - Kosher Australia and Adass Israel in Victoria and the Kashrut Authority in NSW:
  • The three communual agencies employ between 7 and 14 staff each as well as having Boards of Directors above them. It's Kosher only employs the two partners
  • The three communal agencies employ Rabbis and Mashgichim who get paid a set figure each week - a standard which is practiced all over the world to assure no conflict of interest.  R' Rabi and Mr Gradman need to pay themselves from the fees they charge out. On the Ben Pakuah project that he supervises he is on a commission
  • Other hechsherim have numerous Rabbis whose only responsibility is to make sure everything is 100% kosher to the standards of the Rabbonim they consult. While R' Rabi and Mr Gradman are under a lot of pressure as they offer a far more inclusive service:
o   Finding new business
o   Checking out if these businesses are acceptable
o   All contracts and accounts
o   Marketing and advertising on webpage and Facebook
o   Photography to promote products and to promote R’ Rabi - including selfies with a range of prominent Rabbonim around the world
o   Visiting potential customers and Rabbonim to push their hashgocha and products
o   Daily upkeep of their Facebook page
o   Travelling the world regularly
o   Checking SCTV which are used as he claims more reliable than mashgichim. A very conservative estimate on the cameras he claims to have in place comes to a minimum of 3,500 hours footage per week
o   Checking and criticizing the other Melbourne and Sydney hechsherim including writing on blogs and Facebook using fake names (eg. Kelvin Mottel)
  • The “It’s Kosher” business give more new hechsherim than the other main agencies combined (His facebook page is titled “Australia’s largest and most active independent kosher certification authority"!)
Due to this amazing workload we believe R’ Rabi must be a miracle man, a posek more reliable, pious and knowledgeable than any other posek in the world (unless he can find someone who agrees with him) so making a bracha She'osa Nissim makes perfect sense.
It would therefore seem that when seeing this great rabbi of many hats we should also make this bracha.

45 comments:

  1. I have known Meir for close to 40 years.
    He was always a rebel, and always had to be right. Facts never got in his way, he just created new facts. Truth was never too important, as long as he won. Can be pretty stubborn.
    He is smart but must always be the winner.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Does anyone really believe that Meir or Kalaman watch 3,500 hours of CCTV each week. Well I don't.
    The time has come for the ORA (Orthodox Rabbinical Association makes a full audit on the IT'S KOSHER business.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Most Rabbis here are scared of Gradman!!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Sad that such activities can occur in our city.
    Moshiach Now!

    ReplyDelete
  5. The level of Chutzpah and dishonesty by Meir Rabi is simply unbelievable!!
    Falsely misrepresenting prominent Rabbonim as if they agree to what he fantasizes is the Halacha to suit his business.
    First it was Rav Elyashiv re his soft Matzah business, then Reb Chaim Kanievski re his Ben Pekuah business.
    Then his INTERNATIONAL RENOWN POSEK Rav Padwa.
    Well we all know the letter from Rav Kanievski proving how false Rabi is, but I hear that Rav Padwa has also confirmed that Rabi has been saying more fibs in the name of Rav Padwa.
    Rabi says it is a mitzvah to eat Ben Pekuah, but it seems the only Mitzvah Rabi knows is to be DISHONEST.

    ReplyDelete
  6. my rav, told me tonight there is not one rav. in the world who backs up this b/p project, all the gedoli yisroel forbid it,
    but rabi in his usual way will say the opposite

    ReplyDelete
  7. i heard today the story about the money rabi stole from the kollel
    no wonder he was told to leave , he was very lucky the police were not called

    ReplyDelete
  8. any other community would have long ago put him in cherem

    ReplyDelete
  9. I RECALL YEARS AGO HE TRIED TO MAKE A MINYAN IN BNE BRITH THE MITPALLIM SAW THROUGH HIM VERY FAST AND ALL LEFT

    ReplyDelete
  10. How can Rabi claim that this Rabbi Padwa supports his BP when Rabbi Padwa writes it is forbidden.
    Is DISHONESTY the trademark of It's Kosher.
    We'll both partners have been previously caught stealing.

    ReplyDelete
  11. you cant believe a word of rabi

    ReplyDelete
  12. Very sad when a person calls himself Rabbi, makes a living from our religion and has no problem in fooling the community promoting and marketing foods that their kosher status is pretty shaky.
    For Rabi to feel he knows better than all the great Torah sages speaks tons about his personality.
    He would be a good politician, but not a Rabbi as he might be a great spin doctor but not a reliable rabbi!

    ReplyDelete
  13. This Rabi fellow has one problem. Gavah!
    Full of himself.
    A bit of humility would help him a lot.

    ReplyDelete
  14. A little simplistic to think that Rabi has only ONE PROBLEM.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Well I hear Rabi is smiling. He is apparently getting over $6000 per month for marketing the Ben Pekuah business plus he gets 8% of all profits.
    He is also doing very well on all his other Hashgochas, as although it's kosher is cheaper but they have no overheads. Kosher Australia employ 13 people while Rabi and Gradman employ no one.

    ReplyDelete
  16. The other Kashrut organisations are community based but IT'S KOSHER is a private business.
    Since when is "profit" a dirty word?
    Get real!

    ReplyDelete
  17. Nothing wrong to have a private business to make money, even in Kashrus! BUT BEING DISHONEST?
    Saying kosher when it is not?
    Saying cholov yisroel when it is not?
    Disobeying Gedolei Yisroel re Ben Pekuah and dog Matzas?
    Misquoting Rav Chaim shlita?

    This is a scandal!

    ReplyDelete
  18. What in the world is DOG MATZOS??

    ReplyDelete
  19. Sorry meant his SOFT MATZOS!

    ReplyDelete
  20. Does Rabi also think that Kalman Gradman is a Gedolei Yisrael, after cheating many from our community with his insurance business. Stole over $300,000. That is a lot more than what Rabi stole from bet hatalmud.

    ReplyDelete
  21. Don't we accept Teshuva any longer?

    ReplyDelete
  22. only from those who stop sinning

    ReplyDelete
  23. Meir Rabi doesn't sin.
    He just changes the Halacha to suit what he wants.
    He claims even the Chatam Sofer (Died about 170 years ago) would agree with him.
    He is an innovator!

    ReplyDelete
  24. Who gave Rabi a Heter to daven at shira chadasha, which most poskim hold it is conservative?

    Even if he not welcome elsewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Rabi is the sole arbitrator of what is permitted and what is not.
    He doesn't need any Heters for anything.

    ReplyDelete
  26. Mr.Rabi the best thing would be if you pack your bags and leave Australia, you have made enough trouble here,
    no one will miss you

    ReplyDelete
  27. But is it fair to export our trouble to another country?

    Adass did exactly that with Malka Leifer.

    I do not believe it is right!

    ReplyDelete
  28. But they could be deported to some place like Saudi Arabia or Nigeria etc.

    ReplyDelete
  29. Or why not Antartica?

    ReplyDelete
  30. Rabi is going no where!
    Just need to hope that he will change his business, and stop trying to make money by fooling others that his it's kosher certification business is kosher, when it is very far from being Kosher!

    ReplyDelete
  31. he should be forbidden to get involved in kosher supervision

    ReplyDelete
  32. Agree!
    But how is that achieved.
    He will never obey any Rav.
    Maybe Consumer affairs could investigate him and his customers re claiming something is kosher or is chalav Yisroel when it is not.

    ReplyDelete
  33. I heard on Shabbos that consumer affairs are investigating if some of It's Kosher claims on the Internet are correct or if some of it is misleading and false advertising.

    Sad if it will take the Goyim to ensure will get kosher when we expect it!

    ReplyDelete
  34. Feel a little sorry for Meir if he is charged for false advertising. His ego got the better of him.
    His partner Gradman could be in bigger trouble after being previously found guilty for taking over $350,000 from his clients while he was an insurance broker.

    ReplyDelete
  35. Consumer Affairs is just the small problem!

    I Fear that there will be an enormous case against Bloch, Rabi and Gradman coming from the non-Jewish investors of Ben Pekuah. These Australian businessmen invested millions of dollars into this scam as they were fed nonsence that this Ben Pekuah meat will sell all over the world to the kosher market as 'hot cakes'. They were gullible to Rabi and Bloch's many false statements that fooled then in believing that tens of millions of dollars of Ben Pekuah parve meat will be sold to the Kosher market all over the USA and Israel.
    It seems the Ben Pekuah business will be struggling to even sell $5,000 of this meat that all prominent Rabbonim have written is forbidden to produce and not kosher.

    ReplyDelete
  36. These investors sat at this fancy non kosher resturaunt when Bloch and Rabi did the whole marketing presentation for the huge benefits of Ben Pekuah for the kosher market.
    They must be pretty stupid to see this moder straw hat rabbi posing with women all the time and eating away at this non kosher venue to accept what he says about kashrut, with nobody else supporting what he says he is doing. Totally changing Kisher meat after more than 1000 years. Rabi and Bloch definetly knew it is a scam but they thought Rabi with all his spin can bully his way through this and get away with all his dishonest statements.

    ReplyDelete
  37. Apparently Rabi is attacking and cursing those that do not agree with him.

    ReplyDelete
  38. when one sees he has lost and gets desperate that's how they act

    ReplyDelete
  39. This community should not allow its Rabbis to be attacked and defamed by a gangster like Rabi who is willing to sell his soul for a few bucks.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Is it true that there is an emai cursing the Rabbonim, saying that the chabad Rabbonim are RESHOIM due to how they handled some Din-Torah and the Adass Rabbonim being accused that they are financing 'their friend ' Malka Leifer!

    ReplyDelete
  41. yes it is true!
    Some pretty sick emails were sent out to numerous people yesterday.
    Besides what you write it also contained very sick curses that whoever challenges Rabbi Meir Gershon Rabi will suffer unnatural disasters!

    ReplyDelete
  42. It sounds like Rabi is a madman?!

    ReplyDelete
  43. no wonder not one shul doesn't want him !

    ReplyDelete
  44. He is welcome at Shira Chadasha!!

    And feels comfortable there!

    ReplyDelete
  45. i dont believe shira chadasha want rebels /trouble makers

    ReplyDelete